Money & Banking

Where's the best place to change dollars into pesos for a short trip?

raccoon_25393· 6 days ago

I'm heading up to Mexico City in a few days for about three days, and I've heard some places only take cash. I'm planning to change around $200 and I'm trying to work out the least painful way to do it. I bank with Chase and Bank of America and I don't think either of them waives international ATM fees for me, so I'm weighing a few options: order pesos from one of my banks before I go, pull them out of an ATM at the airport when I land, or find a casa de cambio here in Puebla before I leave. Would love to hear what actually works in practice and how much this really costs. Thanks.

25

Comments (20)

pitaya_46773· 6 days ago

In my experience the airport here is actually one of the better places to change money. Clear customs, walk out into the arrivals hall and there is a long row of competing casas de cambio. Walk the whole row and compare the posted rates before you commit, they really do vary from one window to the next.

6
educational_gas· 6 days ago

Best rate is almost always your own bank account at an ATM with a debit card, and at a bank branch rather than one of the free standing machines on the street. When the machine offers to do the conversion for you, answer no and continue in pesos. If you would rather carry cash and change it, the airport here is unusual in that the rates are decent, but walk the entire row first and find the best one at that moment.

7
happy_yam· 6 days ago

I always just pull cash from ATMs. My bank refunds the fees and the rate I get is basically the bank rate, so I have never bothered with the counters.

6
raccoon_25393· 6 days ago

When you say decline the conversion, is that the screen that asks whether I want to be charged in dollars or in pesos?

5
sourdood· 6 days ago

Bank of America charges fairly high fees for this. Five dollars for using an international ATM plus a three percent foreign transaction fee. The five dollars is waived at their partner banks and Scotiabank is one of them. If you order pesos from them instead they will usually inflate the rate by about five percent. For one withdrawal on a short visit I would not overthink it. Your pesos end up costing you roughly 210 dollars all in. If you travel internationally a lot, a Schwab account charges you none of those fees. Whatever debit card you use, decline the rate the ATM offers.

10
raccoon_25393· 6 days ago

I do have the Bank of America debit card, so the Scotiabank ATMs sound like my answer. Thanks for actually breaking down the numbers.

5
magicion1· 6 days ago

Very few places are cash only these days. Off the top of my head: trajineras, Tiendas 3B and some street food stands. 3B would not take my foreign credit card, though I know they take other cards. Worth checking whether your bank has a partnership with a local ATM network, otherwise just use an ATM.

10
energyoutside4360· 6 days ago

3B took my Visa at checkout, so it may depend on the branch or on which card you are using.

8

Wise. Add dollars to the account, convert to pesos in the app and then spend with their card or from Apple Wallet. You can also take pesos out of most ATMs for a small fee, since you have already converted at their rate.

11
pizzapants· 6 days ago

You will not need 200 dollars for three days. I spent less than that in cash over two weeks, and only because I ate street food every day. Everywhere else I used my card.

12
raccoon_25393· 6 days ago

Good to hear. I was worried 200 was going to be too little rather than too much.

4
manatee_70091· 6 days ago

Every casa de cambio sets its own rate. The ones abroad are the worst, then the ones at airports. Expect a markup somewhere in the five to twelve percent range if you change cash at a counter. Best option is still a reputable local bank's ATM.

5

The exchange shops in centro historico gave me the best rate I have found. The ATMs, on the other hand, charge ridiculous fees and half of them do not even work.

8
generic_user_334· 6 days ago

I would go the other way on this one. The airport counters and the exchange shops have the worst rates and commissions. A bank ATM normally charges between 30 and 70 pesos per withdrawal, which is two to five dollars.

3
pelican_22474· 6 days ago

A two hour trajinera ride at Xochimilco with fifteen minutes of mariachi on the boat, two micheladas and some snacks runs about 150 dollars, and it is cash only. Everyone budgets differently, but it is worth carrying more cash than you think you need.

8
traditional_cat6145· 6 days ago

The trajineras will take a card if you book online, and it is the same official price.

5
single_bus· 6 days ago

My suggestion is not to exchange at all. Keep the money in a bank or brokerage account that gives you a no fee debit card and just use local ATMs when you land.

8
adorable_tomato2060· 6 days ago

Cash is less and less necessary in CDMX but it is still nice to have some on you. Street food and tips are where I use it most. One Uber driver asked if I could pay cash, I said no, he declined the trip and I got another car. No big deal.

14

Airport, after you clear customs and immigration. Every exchange counter has its rate posted on the door, so it takes two minutes to compare.

7
old_hedgehog· 6 days ago

I have been talked out of avoiding airport exchanges. For small amounts the convenience is worth it. On my last trip I skipped it and went to the ATM by my hotel, my card did not work there, and finding another one a few blocks away wasted more time than the couple of dollars I saved.

15