General Discussion

Can I build an ofrenda if I'm not Mexican?

agave_46298· 18 days ago

I'm about as white as a person gets, and over the last few years I've lost a lot of people who mattered to me. I've been looking for a way to honour them, and the thing I keep coming back to is building an ofrenda. Before I do it I wanted to ask: is this okay? I want to be respectful about it. Some of the best people who have ever been in my life are Mexican, and I don't want to take something that isn't mine, or get it wrong in a way that would be disrespectful to them. I'm not asking for a rulebook, I'd genuinely like opinions from people who grew up with the tradition. This would be in my own home, for family and friends I've lost.

15

Comments (12)

magnolia_75476· 18 days ago

Nobody here minds other cultures doing it. Just don't try to tell us how ours is supposed to look, and please don't trademark it as a business thing the way Disney did.

14
agave_46298· 18 days ago

I had no idea Disney did that, that's disgusting. Thank you for saying it.

4
nopal_80802· 18 days ago

Mexican here. I'm one of the few who actually grew up with la ofrenda as part of a real family tradition. Your post isn't condescending at all, whatever somebody implied. The lack of serious answers comes from a lot of places: most Mexicans here don't even observe the holiday, and the ones who do take it with a lot of humour. If you're far away and you want to build an ofrenda, please feel free. Just be respectful, follow the tradition, enjoy the journey. The whole point is taking a moment to cherish the lives of the people who finished their journey before us.

12
twovegetable4432· 18 days ago

Culture doesn't come with a copyright. Of course you can.

13
think_garlic· 18 days ago

It's not appropriation if it's appreciation. Just remember that.

12
single_bus· 18 days ago

Yes, you can. Just make sure it has some cempasuchil on it, the orange flowers.

8
dahlia_83621· 18 days ago

It's a beautiful tradition and it helps you feel close to the people you lost. Mexico is one of the most multicultural and accepting countries out there, and as long as you're respectful there's nothing wrong with it. I hope you post photos of your altar.

15
agave_46298· 18 days ago

I've been asking in other communities and people were genuinely awful about it. My friends here told me it was fine, I just wanted to check with people actually connected to the culture.

7
silent_asparagus_96· 18 days ago

If you have to ask permission, maybe just don't? I mean that gently. If it feels foreign or inappropriate to you, maybe there's a more personal way for you to honour them. But if it feels like the right thing to do, do it, and don't let anyone tell you otherwise.

15
agave_46298· 18 days ago

Thank you for being kind about it. I'll take all of that into consideration.

4
macaw_54009· 18 days ago

Yes? What do you think is going to happen if you do?

9
electronic_safe2· 18 days ago

Who's going to stop you? Some stranger on the internet?

6