Housing & Rentals

Rental platform kept our whole security deposit with no receipts

westcoastmex· 20 days ago(Edited)

We rented an apartment in Mexico in 2025 through a company called Homie (HEY HOMIE SAPI DE CV) and moved out at the end of October 2025. It's almost two months later and our security deposit still hasn't come back. Homie says they deducted it for damages and services, but: - They refuse to provide any invoices or receipts - All they shared was a "cotización" (a quote) - They say their vendors invoice monthly, so they can't give proof - When we kept asking for CFDI invoices for completed work, they got evasive — "that's all from us", "saludos" — and eventually stopped responding on WhatsApp Other red flags: 1. The alleged "total damages" matched EXACTLY the remaining balance of our deposit after utilities, which seems very unlikely 2. They later said the deposit would be used for aesthetic refurbishing and repainting, even though we lived there only five months, the colours were there before we moved in, repainting for aesthetics isn't a tenant's responsibility, and the apartment was left clean — yet cleaning charges were included too 3. Earlier, before move-in, the communication about the total payable was misleading: a quote made it look lower, and the higher total (plus an extra 5,000) only became clear after we'd paid a non-refundable deposit. Even the landlord's wife, who is Mexican and speaks fluent Spanish, was shocked by that "misunderstanding" We're foreigners, not fluent in Spanish, and we relied on Homie because they advertise that they protect tenants as well as landlords. In practice they've ignored lawful requests and sided entirely with the landlord. We've already tried: requesting conciliation, waiting past the 30-day return period (it's more than 65 days now), and filing with PROFECO (no response so far — probably because of December). Our questions: 1. If a rental platform refuses to provide invoices, can they legally keep a deposit? 2. Has anyone actually recovered a deposit from Homie or a similar company? 3. Are there effective legal or regulatory options from outside Mexico? We're in our home country right now to be with family after the death of a parent. We're trying to stay factual and reasonable — just asking for receipts for work actually done, or the return of money that doesn't legally belong to them. We want to be back in Mexico soon but we need that money: it was supposed to go towards our (Mexican) child's future and a bit of our return. I have all the WhatsApp threads, emails and payment receipts, I just don't know who can use them to get back what's ours. Thanks in advance — and hopefully this saves someone else from the same situation.

19

Comments (9)

axolotl_27720· 20 days ago

Honestly those platforms are just intermediaries — they don't actually hold your deposit, the landlord does. And unless you have an RFC, a CURP or legal residency, they can't issue you a CFDI anyway, so asking them for one may go nowhere. It leaves you in limbo, especially having already left the country.

6
sourdood· 20 days ago

You'll probably have to go after the landlords. What's the platform's legal responsibility here anyway? Aren't they basically just a tool for matching landlords and tenants?

10
top_pomegranate4899· 20 days ago

Did you sign a contrato de adhesión? If you did, read it — it should state the process for resolving this. If not, check their website, they should have one up. If you never signed one or can't find it, make that the specific argument with PROFECO: there are fines for not having that type of contract. You can argue the lack of contract plus the refusal to reimburse. A company that well known should have made you sign one — sometimes they just have you fill out a questionnaire and build the contract from that.

7
enlamadre420· 20 days ago

I'm so sorry you're going through this. I'm in Mexico City and I'm currently in the middle of a formal claim against the same company for the exact same reasons, and building the case for PROFECO taught me a few things that should help: 1. The CFDI is mandatory. A cotización is NOT legal proof of an expense. They can't legally withhold your money without providing a CFDI for the work. "Our vendors invoice monthly" is an excuse to avoid transparency — if they can't show a CFDI for repairs in your unit, the deduction is illegal. 2. The initial inventory trap. Did you sign a detailed acta de entrega-recepción when you moved in? If they didn't give you one with your signature, they have no legal ground to claim damages — under the civil code the property is presumed delivered in good condition and only normal wear and tear occurred, which they can't charge for. 3. Their own blog contradicts them. They published an article saying the deposit should not be withheld for natural wear and tear like painting or floor polishing. Cite that in your claim as misleading advertising. 4. Timeline. Don't read the silence as a no — December and January are slow months here. If you filed through Concilianet, check whether they're actually registered there; most people end up going in person because the company avoids the online platform. Filed physically, it's about 4-6 weeks to a first hearing. Don't drop it: once the official notification lands they usually get nervous, because the PROFECO fines are much higher than your deposit. Keep every WhatsApp screenshot. From outside Mexico you can appoint someone here with a carta poder to represent you at the hearing, or keep pushing the digital route. They bet on foreigners giving up and leaving the country.

8
runrichrun1· 20 days ago

Deposits going missing is common enough that I stopped paying them. What I do: book on Airbnb, then ask to talk directly and work out a monthly rate under 10,000 pesos furnished — and I say up front that I don't do deposits. Some people will argue that's "how it's done here", but I've rented 30+ places and always found one that's flexible. Offering a previous landlord as a reference helps a lot: I always pay what I owe at the end and keep the relationship good, so that recommendation is what gets me in without a deposit. Keep looking, you'll find a chill landlord.

5
old_hedgehog· 20 days ago

This is really common here. I'd honestly just write it off and move on with life — not worth the hassle.

5
pizzapants· 20 days ago

It's really common in CDMX. I never expect to get my depósito back anymore. Depending on the contract it may or may not be a scam, it's just the norm.

10
happy_yam· 20 days ago

And chasing it usually costs more than the deposit itself. What I do now is invite the owner to check the place out a month before the contract ends and use the deposit as the last month's rent.

3
jackfr_94· 20 days ago

How much are we talking about?

10